Which My Green Mattress Model Is Best? A Detailed Comparison Based On Months Of Testing

Spoiler alert: There’s a lot more to finding the right mattress than just feeling comfortable. Sleep is essential for our health, longevity, and overall well-being, and your mattress plays a huge role in the quality of sleep you’ll get.

At mindbodygreen, we prioritize brands that use organic and natural materials, and our editors have been raving about My Green Mattress. The brand makes two mattresses for adults: the Kiwi and the Natural Escape—but which one is better?

After testing both mattresses extensively (for at least 60 nights of sleep each), we’re giving a deep dive comparison of the My Green Mattress Kiwi vs the Natural Escape.

My Green Mattress is a mattress company with the mission to provide affordable, natural, and sustainable mattresses mattresses (and bedding) at a more affordable price point.

Founder Tim Masters created the brand’s first mattress in 2007 when his infant daughter was battling excess and allergies—and he was left unimpressed by the existing mattress options. 

Now My Green Mattress offers two mattresses for adults—the Kiwi and the Natural Escape—along with an organic kids mattress and an organic crib mattress. Crafted in a certified organic facility in Illinois, each mattress bears impressive certifications such as GOTS, GOLS, GREENGUARD Gold, OEKO-TEX, and Made Safe.

To accurately compare the My Green Mattress Organic Kiwi Mattress and the brand's Organic Natural Escape Mattress, we enlisted two testers with different sleep styles and preferences.

The Kiwi is the brand’s most affordable mattress. The best-seller combines a layer of 1,140 individually pocketed coils with layers of pressure-relieving GOLS-certified organic latex. What really sets the Kiwi apart is its added lumbar support, which helps keep your spine alined while you sleep (no matter your sleeping position).

The brand rates the Kiwi at a 7 (medium-firm) on the firmness scale, making it a great choice for stomach, back, or side sleepers.

Our tester was immediately impressed by the Kiwi. She noted the plush sleep surface was super comfortable, and the design excels in edge support, responsiveness, and motion isolation.

We’d recommend the Kiwi for those who prefer a supportive mattress on the firmer side—and it’s also a great choice for hot sleepers, thanks to a temperature-regulating GOTS-certified organic wool and cotton quilted cover.

Because it's made with coils, the Kiwi does have a bit more bounce than all-foam options. If you're someone who prefers to fully sink into your mattress, the Kiwi is likely not for you.

Great for those who prefer a touch of luxury, the Natural Escape Mattress is a hybrid design with 1,462 individually pocketed coil springs and a 3-inch layer of organic Dunlop latex. It’s made with natural and organic materials and boasts the same certifications as the Kiwi (GOTS, GOLS, GREENGUARD Gold, OEKO-TEX, and Made Safe).

The Natural Escape has a 7-zone lumbar support system, with coils strategically placed to provide added firmness and support around your lower back—and the latex foam helps balance this firm support with pressure-relieving comfort. This design excels in pressure relief, motion isolation, and overall support.

Slightly firmer than the Kiwi, the Natural Escape is rated at a 7.5 on the firmness scale. The brand also sells a two-inch organic latex mattress topper for those who prefer a plusher feel. 

Topper or not, the Natural Escape is another great option for side, stomach, or back sleepers—and it supports total weights of up to 750 pounds.

Our verdict: Kiwi

While both mattresses have reinforced edge support, our testers found the Kiwi to offer better edge support—likely due to the Natural Escape's plusher topper.

Our tester who slept on the Kiwi tends to sleep with an arm or leg hanging off the bed, and she's had no problem with the edges dipping or caving in.

Our verdict: Natural Escape

Our testers just so happen to share their beds with partners who toss and turn—and they were both impressed by the motion isolation on the Kiwi and Natural Escape mattresses.

Our verdict: Kiwi

Not only does good responsiveness make a mattress more comfortable and supportive, it also contributes to durability. Mattresses that are very responsive will bounce back quickly even with repeated pressure, which is particularly important for people who move positions a lot throughout the night.

Our verdict: Natural Escape

We all prefer different firmness levels, but pressure relief is one quality every good mattress should have—and our tester was very impressed by the pressure relief she felt when sleeping on the Natural Escape mattress. Latex is naturally responsive and bouyant, but the foam layer on this mattress gives a hug-like feel.

Our verdict: A tie

There's no clear winner when it comes to materials—or rather, they're both winners. My Green Mattress is dedicated to using natural and organic materials, and both mattresses have certifications to boot.

It's important to note that, while eco-friendly materials are the norm for My Green Mattress, this is not the case for the majority of the mattress industry.

Tasha Stoiber, Ph.D., a senior scientist at Environmental Working Group, previously told mindbodygreen, "The majority of mattresses on the market are made from polyurethane foam based on petroleum chemicals, so it can off-gas volatile organic compounds, which can cause respiratory irritation, skin irritation, etc."

This is one of the main factors that initially drew our editors to My Green Mattress, and we love knowing whichever option we choose from the brand it will be made with materials that are better for you and for the planet.

Our verdict: Kiwi

Neither bed is going to give you that plush, cloud-like feel; but our editors were surprised by how comfortable both the Kiwi and Natural Escape mattresses were. That said, the Kiwi comes out on top because it's slightly less firm.

If you're looking for a comfortable and supportive mattress that's better for the environment, you can't go wrong with either bed from My Green Mattress.