Home Chef vs. HelloFresh: Which Meal Delivery Kit Should You Try?

We know all too well the decision paralysis that can come with deciding what's for dinner. Meal delivery services take the guesswork out of eating healthy—but with so many choices available, it can be difficult to decide between the best options, such as Home Chef vs. HelloFresh. 

Both companies allow you to choose from an ever-changing menu of recipes and send everything you need to make the meals at home, minimal preparation required.

Home Chef is a meal delivery service that brings pre-portioned ingredients to your door, so you can cook a fresh meal without a lot of forethought or preparation.

When you visit Home Chef's website, you'll be prompted to answer a series of questions (i.e., do you want to save time or try new recipes?) and identify any dietary restrictions or preferences.

You can choose from carb-conscious, calorie-conscious, and vegetarian, as well as a handful of foods you might need to avoid, such as pork, poultry, shellfish, tree nuts, and mushrooms. 

From there, you'll choose your box size (two to six recipes per week) and serving size (two, four, or six). 

If you have a larger household, you can opt for the family plan instead of the standard plan, which gives the option for up to 10 meals per week. 

Unlike other meal delivery services, Home Chef does not have specific meal plans. Instead, you have access to the entire menu. 

There are "quick-and-easy" options that will be ready in 30 minutes or less, as well as regular meal kits and a "Culinary Collection" featuring premium ingredients.

Home Chef is a subscription service, so when you sign up, you're committing to weekly deliveries. You can skip or pause a shipment at any time.

You can sign up for more than one meal plan—and regardless of which you choose, you'll have access to the entire menu. In other words, if you sign up for the pescatarian plan, you'll still be able to see options from the veggie plan and so on.

HelloFresh offers two to six recipes per week, with two or four servings for each recipe. Once you've committed to your preferred number of meals, you'll have access to the menu, where you can select which recipes you want to include in your box.

HelloFresh is a meal kit service, so your box will include everything you need to cook the meals (pre-portioned ingredients and recipe cards with detailed instructions on how to make the meals).

Because HelloFresh is a subscription, you'll receive recurring deliveries each week on whichever day you choose. When it's time to build your box, you'll be prompted via email to sign into your account and choose your meals.

Home Chef does things a little differently than other meal delivery services. Instead of charging a fixed price for your box, the final weekly cost depends on which recipes you choose. There are standard recipes and a "Culinary Collection," with premium (and more expensive) ingredients such as scallops and filet mignon.

Home Chef standard meals average around $10 per serving but start at $8 per serving. Again, this varies based on your recipe selections, whether you customize any meals, and the size of your order. There is a minimum order cost of about $51 per week for the regular plan and $83 for the family plan.

HelloFresh plans range from $9 to $12.49 per serving. The largest plan (six weekly meals with four servings each) costs about $9 per serving, while the smallest plan (two weekly meals with two servings each) breaks down to $12.49 per serving.

Both brands also offer discounts to certain groups of people. Home Chef offers 50% off your first box and 10% off all future orders for military, first responders, health care workers, and teachers. Students, alumni, and government officials get 50% off the first four boxes.

Both Home Chef and HelloFresh have new recipes dropping each week. Home Chef has about 40 weekly meal options, while HelloFresh offers about 100 total recipes each week.

Because Home Chef doesn't offer specific meal plans, you'll have access to the entire menu each week. Meals are categorized by preparation speed, with a section for Easy Prep Meal Kits (meals that take 30 minutes or less to prepare) and regular meal kits (meals that take 30 minutes or more to make).

You can customize some Home Chef meals, and if swaps are possible, you'll see a "Customize It" tag on the recipe. For example, if a meal includes pork, you can opt for chicken or shrimp instead. Just note, customizations may change the price.

The Home Chef menu can be filtered by a handful of preferences, such as calorie-conscious, carb-conscious, and vegetarian. Outside of these menu filters, Home Chef doesn't cater much to dietary considerations.

HelloFresh allows you to mix and match recipes from all meal plans, even if you only signed up for one or two.

Like Home Chef, HelloFresh allows you to make some customizations—but there's a limit. You can swap or upgrade 12 sides and proteins per week and request pork-free, beef-free, and seafood-free meals. There are also vegan and vegetarian meals.

Both Home Chef and HelloFresh give the option to add extras to your box.

Home Chef has a wide array of offerings from a la carte proteins (such as mahi mahi filets or New York strip steaks) to desserts. There are also condiments, sides, soups, salads, flatbread pizzas, breakfast options, and bottled drinks, like smoothies and iced coffee.

HelloFresh has breakfasts, light lunch options like soups and flatbreads, baked goods, and seasonal items. You can include as many add-ons as you want and the final cost will depend on which items you add to your box.

HelloFresh has a slight edge when it comes to sustainability. While both companies use recyclable packaging, HelloFresh is 100% carbon-neutral.

HelloFresh uses renewable energy sources and makes a point to use local suppliers whenever possible to help shorten the supply chain (and the impact on the environment).

As for packaging, most of what you get from both companies is either curbside recyclable or able to be dropped off at your local recycling center. Exceptions are the gel ice packs, which aren't recyclable but use biodegradable materials.

Both Home Chef and HelloFresh prioritize animal welfare and source meat and fish only from suppliers who follow industry guidelines for the humane treatment of animals.

Both Home Chef and HelloFresh operate on a subscription model. When you sign up, you'll automatically be agreeing to recurring weekly deliveries.

That said, you'll have the option to skip a delivery at any time, as long as you do so by the cutoff date. You can also pause your subscription if you want to skip deliveries for an extended period of time.

Home Chef and HelloFresh are two of the best meal delivery services available today. The right one for you depends on your household size and how much time you want to spend in the kitchen preparing your meals.