Are Signature Scents Coming To An End? Maybe, But It Might Be A Good Thing

There's nothing wrong with having one perfume you love—but why is there such an ominous pressure to find that signature scent and commit to it with unwavering devotion? 

The core function of fragrance is changing, shifting more toward internal satisfaction rather than people-pleasing. Before recent years, fragrance was generally focused on (and marketed toward) the other. "You would think about your fragrance as part of an allure about yourself that you're trying to create to attract others," clinical psychologist Chloe Carmichael, Ph.D., tells mbg.

This is partially why there was such a stark difference in men's cologne and women's perfume. Musk and woodsy scents were marketed toward men, while classic florals and hints of warm vanilla were essential to a women's blend–with generally zero crossover.

There was also a certain prestige with wearing a big-time, name-brand fragrance, and it was an even bigger flex if another person could smell your perfume as soon as you entered the room. The fragrances created a few decades back were practically made to be devoured and evaluated by others—the intention was to impress, to have your signature scent be memorable and desirable.

"There's a level of intentionality that's going beyond a results-driven approach," Carmichael says. The goal is now to feel something, not impress, attract, or perform. And fragrance marketing is reflecting this shift.

By Rosie Jane, a particularly buzzy clean fragrance brand, describes their products based on how they make you feel, not just the top notes. Phrases like "standing on the porch during a rain storm" or "LA spring days and wine in the afternoon" remind consumers that their product is meant to make you feel something—not find someone.

Rosie Jane Johnston, the founder of By Rosie Jane, finds inspiration for new scents from cities, seasons, elements, emotions, and experiences—all of which are simply human, not gendered. To that end, musks and florals have intertwined to create novel dynamic blends. Even top sellers like 11:11 by Lake and Skye are adored by people of all identities alike—with no emphasis on any masculine- or feminine-forward marketing.

If there's one scent you want to use every day for the rest of your life because you love it—then don't let anyone stop you. But with the evolution that comes with each new year, we must make room for people to switch up their fragrance to match who they are now and how they want to feel, and thus, why the concept of a signature scent just might be on the outs.

"It points to what's really happening in society," Carmichael says. "If we think of fragrance as art, then it's one of those things where we ask, 'Does life imitate art, or does art imitate life?'"